Keep evidence of why closure decisions were made
- Reading time
- 2 minutes
- Last reviewed
On this page
A decision log tells you what was decided. The evidence behind it explains why that decision appeared appropriate at the time.
Keep those two records connected. Do not rely on a later recollection of the reasons, especially when dates, costs or options have changed during the closure.
Attach the evidence available at the decision point
Identify the relevant document versions, advice, factual reports and estimates. Mark which inputs were confirmed and which were assumptions. Preserve the source of a recollection rather than presenting it as a verified record.
The closure decision log can hold the decision and authority reference. The working index can locate the supporting material without copying all of it into the log.
A fictional business decides to delay disposal of one machine because a current production report shows unfinished work. Later, the job is cancelled. The original evidence remains relevant to explaining the earlier decision, even though the current release position may now differ.
Changing the old record to say the machine was always surplus would make the history less accurate. Add the later decision and its evidence instead.
Preserve the uncertainty that mattered
If a choice relied on an estimate, keep its basis and limitations. Do not replace it silently with the final figure and make the decision look more certain than it was.
Similarly, an unanswered adviser question should remain visible in the record of what was known. If a decision was conditional on that answer, preserve the condition. Ask the relevant professional about the appropriate records where legal, financial or formal approval issues are involved.
Advice assumptions help prevent a qualified response becoming an unqualified endorsement through repeated summaries.
Keep the record proportionate and usable
You do not need to reproduce every message about an ordinary scheduling choice. Identify the material evidence and the route to it, using the business's agreed retention and access arrangements.
Sensitive advice, personal information and commercial records may need different controls. A general decision summary can refer to a restricted source without exposing its contents to every project participant.
When a disposal instruction is given to UK Auction Group, keep the relevant scope and authority evidence linked to that issued version. The auctioneer receives the current instruction; the business retains the reasoning and supporting record appropriate to its obligations.
A useful evidence trail lets someone distinguish a reasonable response to the information then available from a later change in circumstances. It should explain the decision honestly, including uncertainty, rather than make every earlier judgement appear inevitable with hindsight.
Explore closure enquiries and records.
Sources
This guide is general information and education only. Legal, tax, employment and safety decisions may need a qualified adviser who knows your situation. Read the disclaimer.